I totally have a non-sexual girl crush on Winona, by the way. I'm still crossing my fingers for her comeback. I don't care that she shoplifted!

Winona, if you're out there, DO SOMETHING! Make another movie!

Oh, and I picked short hair, although she's stunning either way.

She looks great iwth that longer do! more galmorous

I'm all in.

I love both, and her, but I am partial to the pixie do!

I'm really hoping for a Winona comeback too, Whip.
I love the pixie cut most, but either way she looks cute.

she shoplifted?? what did she shoplift?

Her lashes look a bit scary in the first picture!

Love the pixie cut.. it's like an edgy mia farrow. LOVE IT! Tina - she shoplifted clothing .. it was a big mess in the news a few years ago.

I definately like it better short

I love her! I voted for the longer style. I love the pixie cut, but she had that for so long & everyone needs a change.

both are cute, but i like the longer and lighter

I love her, too!! I like both but, I picked the short & dark. I really like her with DARK and long hair, too!!

Strictly between these two pics, I like the longer/lighter better -- but no one can rock the short, spiky pixie-do like Winona.

She looks great either way, but (as with Christina Ricci) she's always best in darkish tones (brown - black). I know she's a natural blond, and I love Edward Scissorhands, but light blond doesn't suit her. (Every now and again, mother nature hiccups and spits out the wrong color.)

Winona - COME BACK!!

She rocks the pixie.

for me she will always have that pixie cut

I like it longer.

short.

i prefer longer